Everybody has been talking about the Obama Administration's proposal for the future of housing finance. While the debate focuses on the virtues or drawbacks of the options laid out in the proposal, fewer people seem to be discussing the impact that the plan could have on home values, home equity, and foreclosures. The proposed reforms lay out three basic options for housing finance reform. In brief, they are:
* Option one - a privatized housing finance system where the government insures a limited number of mortgage loans, specifically FHA, VA, and USDA loans.
cash loan payday, personal loans for poor credit, get a credit card with bad credits,
* Option two - similar to option 1, except that there would be a system whereby the government guaranteed more loans in specific emergency situations.
* Option three - privatized system where the government would provide mortgage assistance for the FHA, USDA, and VA for low and medium-income borrowers.
All of the options in the proposal depend upon private investors to step in for the government when support for the housing market is scaled back. Presumably these private investors would demand a higher return on their money than the government does. This begs the question: are there actually private investors who are willing to step up in the absence of the government, and at what rate will they be willing to lend? It is really hard to say for sure, but one can rest assured that mortgage rates would increase under any of the options outlined in the Treasury's White Sheet.
Generally speaking, there is an inverse relationship between mortgage rates and home prices. As mortgage rates increase, home prices tend to decrease. There is significant disagreement on how greatly rising rates will impact home values, but it is generally accepted that there is some correlation there. Mortgage rates have already risen substantially in the last few months, likely due to the rising stock market and what appears to be rising inflation. Last fall, the average rate on a 30 year fixed rate mortgage was 4.17 percent, as of last week it increased to 5.05 percent. We are seeing the effect of rising rates in the Mortgage Bankers Association's Weekly Mortgage Applications surveys.
The increase in rates has caused a steep decline in applications for new mortgages, especially mortgage refinancing. Less applications correlate to less demand for homes in the near future, which would indicate continued weakness in the housing market. The huge supply of unsold homes in this country, coupled with the lack of demand for homes shifts the equilibrium on the supply and demand curves to a lower price point. Nearly every major home price index is reflecting this to some extent or another, CoreLogic has seen home price declines for five consecutive months, Zillow predicts that home values will continue to fall through 2011, and the S&P Case-Shiller Home Price Index reported that home prices are broadly declining, and a housing market double-dip could be confirmed in the spring.
Yet another factor could have an impact on home values going forward: the new risk-retention requirements due to the Dodd-Frank reforms will cause lenders to retain capital reserves equal to 5 percent of all but the safest loans they originate (these safe loans would be deemed "qualified residential mortgages", or QRMs). The definition of what constitutes a QRM have yet to be determined, but it seems that these loans will likely require down-payments of at least 20 percent. Any non-QRM loan is going to have an increased mortgage rate to compensate the lender for the additional risk. This will serve to drive up rates for some people even further, which will reduce the pool of potential home-buyers.
So what we have right now is a housing market where prices are declining. New risk retention rules and reduction in government support for the market will cause rates to rise, putting more downward pressure on home prices. Already 27 percent of homeowners with mortgages have negative home equity. Further price declines will drive this number up even further, which will in turn cause more and more homeowners to default on their mortgages. Increases in defaults and foreclosures will drag down home prices even further.
While the housing finance model is in desperate need of reform, we need to be sure that any changes are implemented wisely, with an eye on both short and long term ramifications. Recovery of the housing sector is vitally important to the economy as a whole, and the housing sector is presently on life support- removing the support too early could easily kill the patient.
Need Money? Let Me Help You
Take advantage from the innovative CreditGraph lending technology today.
instant approval payday loans
$ 1500 Wired To Your Bank In 1 Hour. No Faxing Payday Loan Advance. No Faxed Document. Approval Takes Only Second. Apply Online Today!
No comments:
Post a Comment